Dark Dubai by Davidson
In the FT, Roula Khalaf reviews "Dubai: The Vulnerability of Success" by Christopher Davidson in her article "Glitzy Dubai has a darker side". And, I would agree, with every ying comes yang. Although the misunderstanding about why the book was banned or not banned does not really seem clear, it can be put down to the fact that Davidson's book gives an accurate picture of the Emirate and how Dubai has pushed itself into the everyday conscience of the man on the street in the West and the East.

For those of you who have not read the book, read the review, and see if it is your chai nana. For those of you that read the book, remember, this book was banned. If you like it, you'll love Dubai Inc by Aamir Rehman. And for those of you that prefer something a little racier, try a real banned book - Dubai, by Robin Moore.
If you prefer a less balanced view, read a newspaper.
"Perhaps most irritating to the Dubai authorities is Davidson’s depiction of the more seedy side of the city, where he says smuggling, arms trading and prostitution are rife. Though the government has stepped up efforts to curb illegal activity, including money laundering, the openness of Dubai has been a magnet for legitimate business as well as illicit activities."
Glitzy Dubai has a darker side
For those of you who have not read the book, read the review, and see if it is your chai nana. For those of you that read the book, remember, this book was banned. If you like it, you'll love Dubai Inc by Aamir Rehman. And for those of you that prefer something a little racier, try a real banned book - Dubai, by Robin Moore.
If you prefer a less balanced view, read a newspaper.
"Perhaps most irritating to the Dubai authorities is Davidson’s depiction of the more seedy side of the city, where he says smuggling, arms trading and prostitution are rife. Though the government has stepped up efforts to curb illegal activity, including money laundering, the openness of Dubai has been a magnet for legitimate business as well as illicit activities."
Glitzy Dubai has a darker side
Labels: Aamir Rehman, by Robin Moore, Christopher Davidson, Dubai, dubai inc, Dubai: The Vulnerability of Success, Roula Khalaf

1 Comments:
Re the Christopher Davidson book on Dubai: the Vulnerability of Success.
Grapeshisha stated:
"For those of you who have not read the book, read the review, and see if it is your chai nana. For those of you that read the book, remember, this book was banned."
Actually, the book was NEVER banned, although Davidson said to the Times Higher Education Supplement a few weeks ago that it HAD been banned, as a result of a "kneejerk reaction" by the National Media Council. At the time he made his statement, the book had not even been received by the National Media Council offices in Abu Dhabi.
Once it HAD been received, it was rapidly passed for distribution, despite the fact that it has numerous, easily-demonstrable factual errors. The NMC's view was that there was no justification for banning a book just because of mistakes of fact.
Far too many mistakes to mention here. A couple that Dubai residents should be able to pick up easily, though.The book states that there was only a dirt track between Abu Dhabi and Dubai until the mid-1990s. Really? I drove the tarmac road between the two in the mid 1970s. And it also said that there was no highway between Dubai and Fujairah until 2006. Really? I drove along THAT piece of tarmac in the late 1970s. And the author was actually living in the UAE before 2006, when his contract with Zayed University was not renewed. Did he never drive over to the East Coast?
Then other errors about relationships inside the ruling familes (of Dubai and Fujairah, for example) about the oil industry in both Abu Dhabi and Dubai, the occupation by Iran of Abu Musa and the two Tunb islands, etc., etc.
Read the book by all means - just be aware that the author's research is not always very accurate!Rather sloppy, in parts
Peter Hellyer
National Media Council
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home